Self-reflexivity means "consciousness turning back on itself," and reflexive cinema is about films which call attention to themselves as cinematic constructs (Siska, 285). Reflexivity points to its own mask and invites the public to examine its design and texture. Reflexive works break with art as enchantment and call attention to their own factitiousness as textual constructs" (Stam, 1).
It is easy to underestimate the pervasiveness of reflexivity in films, for it can be found in such wide-ranging works as the modernist efforts of Jean-Luc Godard, the parodic comedies of Mel Brooks, the homages of Brian De Palma and on television in the 80's series Moonlighting.
While few mainstream movies completely embrace reflexivity, many do incorporate some anti-illusionistic techniques. Thus, not all the movies below are considered wholly reflexive; rather, they integrate some reflexive elements within a framework of traditional storytelling.
Filmic reflexivity and inherent quality are independent; that is, both marginal efforts and cinematic masterpieces (as well as everything in-between) can manifest reflexive techniques. The list below, for example, ranges from Bachelor Party to Amarcord.
Film
within a film: Shakespeare's plays thrive on the "diabolical struggle
between realistic imitation and self-conscious artifice." Likewise, a film
"foregrounds its own artifice through" the implementation of a
film-within-a-film (Stam, 3). A good example is in Legal Eagles, where defense
attorney Robert Redford watches Singin' in the Rain on television. In addition to
depicting a film within a film, Singin' in the Rain is itself a reflexive musical
comedy. Further, Redford doesn't passively watch the screen; he mimics Gene Kelly's
character dancing in the rain. This is reflexive on a third level because
Redford's singing and dancing imitation is a jolt to the viewer who expects to view his
usual screen persona as an earnest, handsome leading man. The audience may well see
Robert Redford, not his filmic character, cavorting on the screen, which is a distancing
technique, the latter being a distancing often found in reflexivity. Other examples are
below:
|
On TV: |
|
|
Afterglow Boiler Room ET Fright Night |
Hannah and Her Sisters
Sleepless in Seattle Truly, Madly, Deeply The Icicle Thief |
|
|
|
| Hairspray Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz Down and Out in Beverly Hills Adams Rib |
Star Man Ruthless People 20 Dates Hamlet (2000) Family Man |
|
|
|
|
Amélie Annie Hall Biloxi Blues Blazing Saddles Cinema Paradiso Diner The Guru The Last Picture Show Leon the Professional |
The Majestic Matinee O Brother, Where Art Thou? One Crazy Summer The Outsiders Sabotage Snow in August Targets Taxi Driver |
Exploration of filmmaking milieu:
Exploration of filmmaking milieu: Again like
Shakespeare's plays, reflexive films are shown "in the very process of their
elaboration" (Stam, 3). Thus, a movie may incorporate any or all of the
following: script conferences; actors' auditions or rehearsals; dressing room and
backstage scenes; doing promotion for a film; and movie titles on a theatre marquee.
|
Adaptation All That Jazz America's Sweethearts Ararat Barton Fink Being John Malkovich The Big Picture Body Double Boogie Nights Bowfinger Bugsy The Cat's Meow Cecil B. Demented 8½ Ed Wood The Exorcist French Lieutenant's Woman Get Shorty Gods and Monsters Good Morning, Babylon Gosford Park Grand Canyon Hollywood Ending The Icicle Thief Irma Vep Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back Living in Oblivion Lulu on the Bridge |
Man With a Movie Camera Modern Romance Mommie Dearest Mrs. Parker and the Vicious Circle Mulholland Drive My Wife Is An Actress Never Give a Sucker an Even Break Notting Hill Peeping Tom The Player Postcards from the Edge RKO 281 Scream 3 Shadow of the Vampire Silent Movie Singin' in the Rain Smell of Camphor, Fragrance of Jasmine A Star in Born Star Maker State and Main The Stunt Man Sullivan's Travels Sunset Boulevard Sweet Liberty Tango The Tango Lesson |
Processes of artistic
reproduction on screen: "Film can
reflect upon the filmic and cinematic fact," and one way is to remind us of "the
mechanics of its transmission" (Fredericksen, 307). "Exposition of the
mechanics of production is common to ... reflexive cinema" (Siska, 286). Cameras
and film apparatus, for example, are visible on the screen.
And the Ship Sails
On
S.O.B.
Tootsie
Day for Night
Real Life
Lenny
The Stunt
Man
Abbott
& Costello Meet the Keystone Cops
Flimsily connected episodes:
Flimsily connected
episodes: The "investigation of reflexivity highlights the shared procedures of the
comic epic of Rabelais, Cervantes, and (Henry) Fielding, and the epic theatre of (Bertold)
Brecht ... All these writers refer back to the original Greek conception of epic as a
specific kind of narrative structure ... Whereas tragedy requires a beginning, a middle
and an end, in both epic and comic epic events are simply laid end to end ... The
structure of Don Quixote ... is episodic -- its incidents could easily have been
reshuffled into a different sequence ..." (Stam, 6, 7).
Mr. Hulot's
Holiday
The Blues Brothers
A Hard Day's
Night
The Mad Adventures of
Rabbi Jacob
Modern Times
O Lucky Man
Oh Brother, Where Art
Thou?
Never Give a Sucker an
Even Break
The Shining
(J. Nicholson)
All of Me (Steve Martin)
Pee Wee's Big
Adventure
True Romance (Gary Oldman)
The Birdcage (Nathan
Lane)
The
Rocky Horror Picture Show
101 Dalmations (Glenn
Close)
Batman
The Devils Advocate (Al Pacino)
Me,
Myself and Irene (Jim Carrey)
The Adventurers of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert
| And the Ship Sails
On The Rocky Horror Picture Show The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? Hairspray Planet of the Apes (2001) Cecil B. Demented Edward Scissorhands The Princess Bride Snow White: A Tale of Terror Romeo and Juliet (1996) Sleepy Hollow Hedwig and the Angry Inch Mulholland Drive |
PeeWee's Big Adventure Suspiria Dick Tracy Brazil 102 Dalmations Birdcage La Cage aux Folles Beetlejuice Ed Wood True Stories Bride of Frankenstein Blow Dry Strictly Ballroom 101 Dalmations Moulin Rouge |
Getting
the audience into the act:
Reflexive films "foreground the complicity of the
filmmaker/spectator relationship in creating artistic illusion" (Stam,
xiii).
Deconstructing Harry
The Purple Rose of
Cairo
Sherlock, Jr.
Editing
processes calling attention to themselves: split screen, slow motion, freeze frame, pronounced wipe, etc.
|
The Battleship Potemkin Deconstructing Harry Day for Night Tom Jones The Opposite of Sex Napoleon |
Jesus' Son Ruthless People Pillow Talk Down With Love Shaft (2000) Run Lola Run Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid |
The Marshmallow Man in Ghostbusters
Gene Kelly's mouse dance partner in Anchors Away
Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
Casper
Kill Bill: Vol. I
Space Jam
Run Lola Run
Natural Born Killers
And Now for Something Completely Different
Hedwig and the Angry Inch
One Crazy Summer
Analogy between
lens/eye, shutter/eyelid: Another of Vertov's "visible puns"
(Stam, 82).
Un Chien
Andalou
Peeping Tom
Rear Window
Poking fun at on-screen sex:
One reflexive technique, à la Godard, is the
"sabotage of eroticism." Godard "defuses" and "subverts" sex
scenes, playing up their inherent comic absurdity (Stam, 56).
| Naked Gun
series
Scary Movie American Pie (all three) There's Something About Mary Shallow Hal Young Frankenstein All of Me M*A*S*H The Sweetest Thing |
Bob&Carol&Ted&Alice Deconstructing Harry Twins The Seven Year Itch Some Like It Hot The Real Blonde Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Sex... Not Another Teen Movie |
Direct
address to camera: One anti-mimetic device is the "direct
address by a character to the audience ... or `face-on' shots ... Acknowledging the
audience points to the film as film, produces irony and weakens the `impression of
reality'" (Fredericksen, 306, 312).
Albert Finney in
Tom Jones
Cleavon Little and Harvey Korman in Blazing
Saddles
Any Marx Bros. movie (usually Groucho engages us)
Matthew Broderick in Ferris
Buellers Day Off
Sam Elliott at end of The Big Lebowski
Tilda Swinton in Orlando
Woody Allen in Annie Hall
John Cusack in High Fidelity
Director Miles Berkowitz in his film 20
Dates
John Belushi in Animal House
Appearance of filmmaker in film, especially in role of creative or artistic capacity:
Reflexivity may appear with "the artist as creator reflecting upon
himself ... in films about the moviemaker" (Siska, 285-6). Authors appear either
actually or figuratively, through delegates ("authorial surrogates") (Stam,
127). For example, Pierre Léaud as Antoine Doinel is François Truffaut's alter ego in
the series of films depicting the boy's growth to manhood (as well as in Day for Night),
and Marcello Mastroianni appears on screen as Federico Fellini's stand-in in several of
il Maestros films.
Truffaut in
The Wild Child, Day
for Night
Woody Allen in Manhattan, Deconstructing Harry, Manhattan Murder
Mystery
Albert Brooks in Modern Romance,
Defending Your Life, Mother, The Muse
Mel Brooks in High Anxiety, Silent Movie, Space Balls, History of the World Part I
Spike Lee in Shes Gotta Have It, Do the Right
Thing, Jungle Fever
John Sayles in The Return of the Secaucus Seven,
Brother from Another Planet, etc
Barbara Streisand in Yentl, The Prince of Tides, The
Mirror Has Two Faces
Martin Scorsese in Taxi Driver, King of Comedy,
After Hours, The Age of Innocence
Maurizio Nichetti in The Icicle Thief
Kevin Smith in Clerks, Mall Rats, Chasing Amy, Dogma,
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back
Quentin Tarantino in Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction,
From Dusk Till Dawn
Use of
parody: "Reflexiveness is
a strategy long known in film, found in early comedies that parody `serious' dramatic film
hits, and in the subgenre of comic and dramatic films that use film-making as their
ambiance or as the object of their fun and scrutiny" (Fredericksen, 302).
Various screen versions of
Frankenstein parodied in Young Frankenstein
David Lynch's Wild at Heart
contains numerous humorous references to The Wizard of Oz
Send-ups of the gangster genre show up in Johnny
Dangerously and Prizzi's Honor
Westerns, musicals and The Blue
Angel are spoofed in Blazing Saddles
70's Blaxploitation films are parodied in I'm
Gonna Git You Sucka
Soapdish
makes fun of daytime soap operas
Star Wars is
made fun of in Space Balls
Used People and American Pie toy with The
Graduate
Spy movies are sent up in Top Secret!
Fifties-era sci-fi is spoofed in Mars Attacks! and
Matinee
Rocky
is
satirized in Ruthless People
Star Trek
is
spoofed in Galaxy Quest
In Me, Myself and Irene, Jim Carrey is a mild-mannered cop whose alter
ego has Dirty Harry's voice
Scream 3 features a film about the murders in Scream
1 and 2
Scary Movie not only makes fun of horror films, but it also lampoons
The Matrix, Amistad, Beetlejuice, Schindler's List, The Sixth Sense,
Titanic, and others
Homage: One way films focus on filmmaking is by employing "intertextual quotes."
This involves two separate texts, or films, with one transforming, modifying, elaborating or extending the other (Stam,
25, 265). Sequels (Jewel
of the Nile, follow-up to Romancing the Stone; The Godfather, Parts
II and III); remakes (Warren Beatty's Heaven Can Wait, first made as
Here
Comes Mr. Jordan and Eddie Murphy as The Nutty Professor, first
done by Jerry Lewis), and adaptations from other media (The Apprenticeship of Duddy
Kravitz and Joshua Then and Now, both adapted for the screen from novels by
Mordecai Richler) all qualify. A prime example is Clerks, in which two characters
have an unforgettable discussion about the first three Star Wars
films. Another
Kevin Smith movie, Dogma, also refers to many other films, including
Krush
Groove, The Piano, The Ten Commandments, E.T., Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade,
various John Hughes films, and of course, Star Wars. Other such
self-reflexive examples can be found below:
One True Thing,
Wild at Heart (The Wizard of Oz)
Play It Again, Sam (Bogart films)
Love and Death (The Battleship Potemkin)
What's Up, Doc? (classic screwball comedies)
Sleepless in Seattle (An Affair to Remember)
High Anxiety (North by Northwest)
Body Double (Vertigo)
The Untouchables (Potemkin)
The Freshman (The Godfather, Part I)
The Limey
incorporates
scenes from Poor Cow, made 20 years earlier
Mickey Blue Eyes (various gangster films)
Boiler Room (characters watching Wall
Street and mouthing dialogue verbatim)
Disjuncton of aural/image scale:
Similar to the
distortion of the time/space continuum, this is in contrast with mimetic films which
reconstitute "a recognizable auditory world, lending depth to visual image"
(Stam, 262).
Ben walking Mrs. Robinson to her front door in
The Graduate
The ferry boat scene in Funny Girl
Sound "derealizing" image:
In a reflexive work,
sound, including music, often counterpoints the image instead of "underlining"
it (Stam, 261).
Musical finale of
Life of Brian
Singin' in the Rain during violent scene in A Clockwork Orange
Music at end of Dr. Strangelove
Western tune in The Big Lebowski, an urban tale
Warner Bros. cartoon theme, Cole Porter tune, Count Basie in Blazing Saddles
Pop tunes, eg, Like a Virgin and Smells Like Teen Spirit in
Moulin Rouge
POSTSCRIPT: One of the most self-reflexive films of the past few years is Austin Powers in Goldmember. Here are some of the ways in which this outrageous comedy is reflexive:
It's a spoof of the James Bond series, including such films as Goldfinger, Octopussy and The
Spy Who Loved Me
It's the third in a series of Austin Powers films, and there are even
scenes from the previous two movies spliced into Goldmember
Michael Caine costars as Austin's father.
His role here echoes the late 60's hit film Alfie, in which Caine is a
womanizer, as well as the series of films in which Caine plays spy Harry Palmer
(including The Ipcress File)
The major female character, Foxxy Cleopatra, is a
take-off on blaxploitation heroines Foxxy Brown and Cleopatra Jones
The character of Dr. Evil, as well as the fact
that he's played by Mike Myers, recalls Peter Sellers' multiple roles in Dr.
Strangelove.
There's a film within-a film featuring several
megastars, including John Travolta, Kevin Spacey, Danny DeVito, Gwyneth Paltrow
and Tom Cruise (in a Mission Impossible spoof), with Steven Spielberg
directing. Composers Burt Bachrach (who wrote the theme song to the film
Alfie,
mentioned above) and Quincy Jones show up, as well.
Dr. Evil appears locked in a cage much like
Hannibal Lecter in Silence of the Lambs
Father/son difficulties echo the problematic
relationship that develops between Anakin and Luke Skywalker in the Star Wars
films
Austin does a soft shoe reminiscent of the title
number in Singin' in the Rain
Japanese horror films such as Godzilla
are
spoofed
At one point, Austin knowingly acknowledges at the
audience
The
scene at Studio 69 is a nod to the film Studio 57, in which Myers plays
real-life disco owner Steve Rubell
A flashback to young Austin and Dr. Evil at spy
school pays homage to Harry Potter
Several sets, including Austin's "pad,"
and many costumes are over the top
One character bursts into a musical number from Yentl
and mentions Barbra Streisand
SOURCES
Fredericksen, Don.
"Modes of Reflexive Film." Quarterly Review of Film Studies, 4.3 (Summer
1979): 299-320.
Siska, William C. "Metacinema: A Modern Necessity."
Literature/Film Quarterly, 7.1 (1979): 285-9.
Stam, Robert. Reflexivity in Film and Literature:
From D. Quixote to Jean Luc Godard.
New York: Columbia University Press, 1992.